Fashion magazines Photoshop problems continue

There has been yet another problem with a fashion magazines use of Photoshop this past week. Over-editing and excessive retouching are continuing to cause embarrassment and problems for magazine publishers. This week the fashion magazine Modeliste pulled an entire printed issue of the publication before it went into circulation after being publicly shamed for using highly-edited images of Zendaya, a model, actress and singer. This is a case of an editor doing everything we discourage in the Photoshop classes and retouching classes at American Graphics Institute.

While some singers and actresses are thought to Photoshop their own images before sharing them publicly, Zendaya is taking the opposite approach. In a post on Instagram, she argues against excessive retouching. She wrote “I found my 19 year old hips and torso quite manipulated. These are the things that make women self conscious, that create the unrealistic ideals of beauty that we have.” She goes on to thank the magazine for removing the excessively retouched images. The magazine released a separate statement indicating that an outside image editor had worked on the photos, and that they would instead post revised images.

It is easy to see why Zendaya was not happy with the retouching. In a poor use of Photoshop, the hips were over-sculpted and the legs were compressed to an unnaturally thin state. While she rightfully complained about the disfiguration, the color correction as equally as bad. The post-Photoshop images includes uneven coloring from one leg to the next, and across her head, neck, and chest as an effort was made to use Photoshop to create a plunging neck-line.

The images edited for Modeliste are a perfect example of what to not do in Photoshop, and serve as a warning for others involved in image editing roles. Keep your images looking natural and believable. Otherwise the attention is focused on the Photoshop work and not on the original intent of the photos.

Zendaya released the original image, shown on the right, and the Photoshopped image on the left side.